Library Design Showcase
The Customer's Always Right
Brian Mathews
Mon, 08/16/2010 - 10:45
To thrive, the library must be an essential component of the community’s educational infrastructure
We strive to provide great customer service, yet few of us actually use the “C” word. We have many names—patron, borrower, user, reader—but “customer” remains controversial and typically we avoid it. Not so at Howard County Library, located in the Baltimore suburbs. At HCL, they embrace the term, feeling that it accurately conveys the relationships they are building with their community.
This is part of using strategic vocabulary. “Circulation” became the “customer service desk.” “Librarians” and “library associates” became “research specialists” and “instructors.” “Programs” were tagged “workshops,” “seminars,” or “events.” And, perhaps most controversially, “storytimes” became “children’s classes.”
HCL President and CEO Valerie Gross explains, “We use smart terminology in order to be more intuitive,” adding, “We want to be very clear about what we do, how we do it, and how we talk about it.”
Gross has strategically positioned the library inside the realm of education. This is evident from HCL’s mission statement: “We deliver high-quality education for all ages” and by the use of the term “curriculum” to describe the library’s agenda of providing instructive and transformational experiences. HCL operates very much like a business and behaves like an academic organization.
The library’s most successful initiative is A+ Partners in Education, an ambitious collaboration with the local schools. Each of the county’s K–12 public schools is assigned a branch library along with a liaison. Library staff work closely with teachers in planning assignments, assisting with access to instructional content and research field trips, and celebrating academic achievement. Gross says, “The aim is to bring the library into the schools, as well as to bring the schools into the libraries.”
This effort has paid off. Not only has the library seen a rise in gate counts and borrowing, but it has also solidified a strong relationship with the community through events such as a regional spelling bee and a reading competition dubbed Battle of the Books. According to Gross, when county executives had to make a 3% budget reduction last year, the main sectors that were impacted were transportation and community services. Education, under which the library resides, was left untouched. “It’s important that we align ourselves with what is valued most in our community,” she observes.
Success fuels ambition, and HCL recently revealed its aspirations for the future. A top priority is to focus on key subject areas including health, environment, finance, and science education. The library will also explore virtual instruction, which would reach more people online through webinars, videocasts, and classes.
Another area of concentration is the customer experience. HCL will form a customer insights team tasked with gathering and assessing data, implementing new strategies, and examining service perceptions and expectations. One goal is to increase “customer convenience” through “impulse borrowing” and other merchandising techniques, shifting collections to maximize visibility, and studying usage patterns both online and within the buildings.
Retention is another prominent theme: 90% of the community has library cards, so the library is looking at ways to build incentives for frequent borrowers. Another focus is to place an emphasis on making a strong first and second impression as well as creating a lasting impression that leads to fiercely loyal customers.
Gross admits to being inspired by Nike’s outreach tactics and strives to make a similar emotional connection with her customers. “Education is timeless; 200 years from now, self-directed education will still be critical for economic advancement and quality of life, and the public libraries that embrace this will always be center stage, regardless of the current technology.” She contends that we shouldn’t just strive for relevancy, but rather, that we should embed the library so that it becomes an indispensable component of the community.
Brian Mathews is a librarian at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and the author of Marketing Today’s Academic Library (ALA Editions, 2009). This column spotlights leadership strategies that produce inspirational libraries.
Trending Now
Current Issue
American Libraries Magazine | 50 East Huron | Chicago, IL 60611 | 2013© American Library Association | Staff Login










Comments
Maryland is Different
I think most of us who’ve worked in public libraries for any length of time are absolutely in support of working closely with the schools and promoting a joint vision that supports learning. For many of us it is truly a daunting task because of the sheer number of school districts we serve. I want to remind everyone that Maryland is truly heaven in the sense that there are 24 public school districts in the entire state, one serving each county and Baltimore City. It’s much easier to develop a shared vision and common language when there are just a couple of you at the table. I mean no disrespect to the valiant efforts of Ms. Gross and HCL, but try this in a library system that serves multiple districts and then I’ll be impressed. Besides, whatever happened to the idea of the public library as an escape from education? We’re about curiosity, igniting the life of the mind and LEARNING. Not so sure I want to learn to speak education-ese.
It's not what you say, it's what you do
Lewis Carroll aptly illustrated the misuse of words in his dialogue between Alice and Humpty Dumpty: ‘When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.’ ‘The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean so many different things.’
George Orwell’s essay, Politics and the English Language catalogs contemporary "swindles and perversions" of language. No doubt both writers would be amused by efforts like this to suggest that libraries are something they are not or are not something they are.
Call your customers and your workers and your products anything you like but the bottom line is that you must exceed user expectations. It’s the quality of your work and how well you meet your customers’ needs, not the words you use, that will determine the value your users attach to your institution. Libraries will prosper when they focus their energies on lowering their users’ costs for discovery and delivery and on providing a welcoming and lively place in the hearts of their communities for the exchange of ideas and information. Our many competitors are succeeding at monetizing the very services we have always provided for "free" because people today value convenience, not because Amazon is using tarted-up language.
I’ve always found this trend
I’ve always found this trend to switch from patron to customer a bit baffling. I’m not sure customer communicates anything more (or anything better) than patron and, in fact, think that patron communicates something extra positive—that this is your place and you are our patron—we’re here because of you. Customer simply communicates that the library is nothing more, or different than a store.
You're right
Patron—noun, a person who supports with money, gifts, efforts, or endorsement. A customer is not much more than a buyer or consumer. I attribute this trend to the over emphasis these days on being politically correct and the word patron to some connotes an element of maleness.
I attribute this trend of
I attribute this trend of using "customer" to the push to run everything according to a business model…whether it’s appropriate or not. I am all for efficiency in the library, but I do not think schools and libraries should be run as a business.
In fairness, they try to use
In fairness, they try to use the term "learner" as much as possible too.
"Learners"
So the "learner" is always right? See how ridiculous this analogy gets when pushed even a little?